The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania opened the door to allowing patients to sue for negligent infliction of emotional distress. No physical injury needs to accompany the claim.
Here’s the background. In March, 2003 (yes, 9 years ago), Jeanelle Toney was pregnant and had a pelvic ultrasound. She was assured the results were normal and no fetal abnormalities were identified.
In July, 2003, Toney delivered a boy with significant abnormalities – including partial arms and legs. Toney sued the radiologist who read the scan for negligent infliction of emotional distress. The lawsuit alleged the radiologist had not prepared her for the inevitable shock of witnessing the birth. The experience left her with ongoing grief, rage, nightmares, insomnia, etc. Of note, the suit did not include any medical negligence claim. A typical medical negligence claim must assert physical damages.
A lower court dismissed the lawsuit. It was reversed on appeal. And the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania agreed in December, 2011 that the mother could indeed sue for emotional distress only.